Welcome to Wider Europe, RFE/RL’s e-newsletter specializing in the important thing points in regards to the European Union, NATO, and different establishments and their relationships with the Western Balkans and Europe’s Japanese neighborhoods.
I am RFE/RL Europe Editor Rikard Jozwiak, and this week I’m drilling down on two points: the EU’s coaching mission for Ukrainian troopers and the primary takeaways from the listening to on the EU’s new enlargement commissioner.
Word to Readers: Now you can take heed to my briefings by clicking on the audio hyperlink under. We’re really utilizing an AI model of my voice and would like to know what you assume — and, after all, what we will enhance.
Briefing #1: EU Coaching Mission To Ukraine To Proceed — However No Boots On The Floor
What You Want To Know: As European Union ambassadors on November 6 woke as much as the information that Donald Trump will return to the White Home early subsequent 12 months, they took the little-heralded however somewhat symbolic choice to delay by two years the European Union Army Help Mission in help of Ukraine — EUMAM Ukraine, for brief.
This mission was first accredited by the bloc’s member states within the fall of 2022. In response to an idea observe from the time, it was arrange “with the strategic goal to contribute to enhancing the navy capability of the Ukrainian armed forces with a purpose to help Ukraine in its wrestle towards Russia’s conflict of aggression.”
By late November of that very same 12 months, EUMAM Ukraine was welcoming the primary Ukrainian troopers for coaching on EU soil. And by the tip of this 12 months, near 75,000 Ukrainians could have obtained coaching from EU international locations. On condition that the preliminary plan was to coach round 15,000 troopers, it may well definitely be stated that the mission has delivered.
Below a Trump presidency, there are fears in Brussels that the EU must shoulder extra of the burden of monetary and navy help for Ukraine. Western funding to the tune of $50 billion, masking the whole lot of 2025, was agreed by the Group of Seven (G7) main industrialized nations in late October. By comparability, EUMAM Ukraine value simply 362 million euro ($388 million) during the last 12 months.
It’s exactly these kinds of initiatives, thought-about cost-efficient by diplomats, that the Europeans may more and more have to show to. Consequently, the annual price range for EUMAM Ukraine is predicted to extend to 408 million euros over the subsequent couple of years and will likely be financed by the European Peace Facility (EPF), an off-EU price range automobile during which EU member states pay in a share primarily based on their gross nationwide earnings (GNI).
Deep Background: Since final 12 months, Hungary has blocked a number of tranches of EPF cash going to EU member states. (The thought is that these member states ship arms to Ukraine after which get compensated by means of the EPF.)
EUMAM Ukraine has, nonetheless, been green-lighted by Budapest, despite the fact that it wasn’t fully frictionless. There was an concept that the bloc would increase the mission to incorporate EU coaching of Ukrainian troopers inside Ukraine. Nonetheless, this was vetoed by Hungary, plus many different member states are strictly towards any “EU boots on the bottom” — one thing that France has been pushing for.
These in favor of increasing the mission argued that it wasn’t navy personnel being despatched to Ukraine however one thing extra akin to directors overseeing coaching workout routines.
In the long run, the choice was just lately taken to delay the mission however with no expanded mandate and only a barely elevated price range. There will even be a strategic evaluation of EUMAM Ukraine performed in early 2025 to see if new issues are wanted.
Drilling Down
- Within the ultimate settlement on EUMAM Ukraine, seen by RFE/RL, there’s one other fascinating ingredient: “the mandatory trade of categorized info must be approved between EUMAM Ukraine and NATO Safety Help and Coaching for Ukraine (NSATU).” NSATU is basically the NATO equal of EUMAM Ukraine with a 700-person headquarters opening in Germany this fall. It’s a small political breakthrough that the 2 Brussels-based organizations will really cooperate, one thing that traditionally has not proved straightforward.
- This solely results in inevitable questions in Brussels: Why are each NATO and the EU operating coaching missions for Ukrainian troopers? And would not it’s extra environment friendly if just one Western group did so to keep away from duplication? The reply from each NATO and EU officers is normally that every one efforts are welcomed by Kyiv — and it’s good that the EU is engaged in exhausting safety measures, particularly if a brand new U.S. administration withdraws help for NATO coaching sooner or later.
- All that apart, EUMAM Ukraine is only a drop within the ocean. A high-ranking Ukrainian official, who wasn’t approved to talk on the file, advised me just lately that EUMAM Ukraine “covers only a fraction of our wants.” And whereas it provides strong and up-to-date coaching, for instance, in areas akin to demining and cyberwarfare, it doesn’t give Ukraine what it needs most of all: heavy artillery (together with the permission to make use of it deep inside Russian territory) and ammunition.
- An EU official, additionally talking anonymously, put it to me much more bluntly: “It is good that it’s there, and they’re doing helpful issues, however it isn’t the issues that Kyiv most desperately wants now. It is a typical European resolution — let’s do one thing, something, that we then can talk as a significant win.”
- And whereas there’s no difficulty with cash within the upcoming 12 months, funds will likely be a difficulty sooner or later. The EU’s European Exterior Motion Service (EEAS) has proposed that EPF must be topped up by way of “voluntary contributions” somewhat than EU members paying in a compulsory share primarily based on GNI. Whereas this methodology would circumvent potential future vetoes, by stripping nonpaying international locations of an opportunity to dam, some member states are afraid {that a} voluntary scheme would permit some international locations a free experience.
- On this context, I perceive that the bloc’s attorneys are presently trying on the EU treaties to verify whether or not the frequent EU price range, which presently stands at over a trillion euros, can be utilized for protection spending as nicely. Historically, that hasn’t been the case, however with the continuing conflict in Ukraine, that might nicely change within the years to return.
Briefing #2: What We Would possibly Count on From The EU’s New Enlargement Commissioner
What You Want To Know: Potential EU Enlargement Commissioner Marta Kos obtained the thumbs-up from the European Parliament’s Overseas Affairs Committee in Brussels on November 7. The Slovenian, a former journalist, businesswoman, and diplomat, may now be sworn in with the remainder of the brand new European Fee earlier than the tip of this 12 months.
Throughout her three-hour listening to, Kos repeated the speaking factors of so lots of her predecessors: that EU enlargement is “a marathon not a dash;” that the accession course of for brand spanking new members is “merit-based with no shortcuts;” and that enlargement provides “a historic alternative to realize peace, freedom, and prosperity on the entire continent.”
Kos added, nonetheless, that the EU should reform earlier than welcoming new international locations and that she would push for a doubling of monetary help for civil society and media in susceptible EU neighborhood international locations.
Deep Background: Essentially the most fascinating factor to look out for when a potential EU enlargement commissioner is being grilled is that if the individual mentions any time frames as to when the membership may increase. Along with her mandate operating until 2029, may she oversee the primary new addition(s) to the EU since Croatia joined in 2013?
Kos did not decide to any dates relating to when the bloc may admit new members, including that “at the moment, for the primary time after 10 years, there’s a actual likelihood that we are going to convey one or two international locations to the tip of the negotiating course of.”
She then identified the bold objectives of Montenegro wanting to finish its talks with Brussels on the finish of 2026 and Albania in 2027. She additionally stated that Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic had just lately underlined that he was keen to do every little thing to align his nation’s laws with that of the EU.
It was maybe telling that she did not point out North Macedonia in any respect. Kos was repeatedly quizzed by Bulgarian EU parliamentarians on the contentious difficulty in North Macedonia of amending the structure to incorporate Bulgarians as a founding individuals, one thing Skopje has repeatedly didn’t do and which has slowed down the nation’s accession bid.
Predictably, Kos got here down on Sofia’s facet, indicating that the pursuits of EU member states “after all come first” and that the bloc “can’t import bilateral points.” North Macedonia now seems to be additional again in line in comparison with Albania, Montenegro, and even Serbia.
Drilling Down
- So, what about Ukraine? Nothing a lot concrete other than Kos saying in her introductory remarks that “enlargement negotiations are the European guiding star for this courageous nation,” including that the identical was true for Moldova. She additionally confirmed that Ukraine seemingly can be her first vacation spot as enlargement commissioner and that, whereas the EU had already began the reconstruction course of, funding from the non-public sector will likely be wanted going ahead as nicely.
- There was one massive omission. Whereas mentioning each Ukraine and Moldova in her introduction, along with the Western Balkans, Turkey, and even the potential of “fostering peace with Armenia and Azerbaijan,” she skipped Georgia utterly.
- The truth is, when requested by a parliamentarian about her view of the South Caucasus republic, the place contested parliamentary elections in late October have left the EU scuffling with a response, she stated that she had a message to the individuals of Georgia: “Do not surrender hope.”
- She stated that she can be able to resume the enlargement course of with Georgia however solely after the sitting authorities, which in recent times has taken an more and more authoritarian strategy, abolishes the just lately adopted “foreign-agent regulation” and “anti-LGBT regulation.”
- There was not a phrase on the elections, however there was a sign that Brussels continues to be ready to work with the ruling Georgian Dream celebration. The professional-EU opposition in Georgia will seemingly not be thrilled with that nearly “business-as-usual” strategy.
- Away from the classical enlargement beat, Kos did trace that she goals to play a much bigger position within the EU-facilitated dialogue between Serbia and Kosovo, which the brand new EU overseas coverage chief, Kaja Kallas, will oversee and could possibly be approached otherwise this time round. She supplied few hints however did make one factor crystal-clear: there will likely be no land-swaps within the Western Balkans. “It’s out of the query. We is not going to observe these tendencies,” she stated.
- In any other case, she managed to swerve a few of the extra politically loaded questions. When pressed on Serbia’s failure to align with EU sanctions on Russia, she appeared contradictory, first saying it was not a situation through the enlargement course of however then admitting {that a} one hundred pc alignment is critical earlier than turning into a member.
- Kos additionally ducked a number of questions on doable sanctions on Serbia over the Banjska assault in September 2023, when dozens of ethnic Serb gunmen attacked a police unit in northern Kosovo. Equally, she didn’t reply whether or not the bloc’s restrictive measures on Kosovo, in place since final 12 months over rigidity within the Serb-majority northern a part of the nation, must be lifted and nor did she give particulars about how she would deal with the separatist tendencies of Milorad Dodik, the chief of the Republika Srpska entity in Bosnia-Herzegovina.
- Most of the similar questions are anticipated when the possible EU overseas coverage chief Kaja Kallas faces the EU parliamentarians afterward November 12. The previous Estonian prime minister is predicted to be one of many key gamers in Brussels within the years forward, particularly if she will form a coherent EU overseas coverage on every little thing from Ukraine to the Center East.
Trying Forward
There’s a curious case within the Basic Courtroom, one of many courts making up the Courtroom of Justice of the European Union, on November 13. The State Border Guard Service of Ukraine has requested the judges to annul a 2023 choice by the Workplace of the European Union for Mental Property (EUIPO) to refuse to register the well-known utterance, “Russian warship, go f*** your self,” as a trademark within the EU.
The phrase turned well-known within the early phases of the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022 when a border guard used it in a standoff with an approaching Russian warship.
The Ukrainian border guard service had initially tried to register the slogan, because it was getting used on garments and different merchandise, however the request was struck down by the courtroom on the grounds that it was a “political slogan devoid of distinctive character for the products and providers in query.” Let’s examine what occurs this time round.
That is all for this week! Be happy to succeed in out to me on any of those points on Twitter @RikardJozwiak, or on e-mail at jozwiakr@rferl.org.
Till subsequent time,
Rikard Jozwiak
In the event you loved this briefing and do not wish to miss the subsequent version subscribe right here.